Response to FDA statement on preventing youth access to flavoured products
13 March 2019
This is the Group’s response to today’s ‘Statement from FDA Commissioner Scott Gottlieb, M.D., on advancing new policies aimed at preventing youth access to, and appeal of, flavoured tobacco products, including e-cigarettes and cigars’.
A British American Tobacco spokesperson said:
“We welcome the FDA (U.S. Food & Drug Administration) shining a spotlight on the important issue of youth access to vapour products. We have always been clear that youth should not use vapour products and have had stringent measures in place to address this for some time.
“In relation to today’s announcement, we share the FDA’s concerns that some flavours, such as those resembling ‘kid-friendly’ food products, may play a role in increasing youth appeal and that marketing activities should not be directed to youth. We have never marketed such vapour flavours; we have supported measures to remove vapour products intended to mimic children’s food products or otherwise designed to target youth and have procedures in place to ensure our products are only marketed to adult tobacco consumers.
“We believe flavours are important in helping adult smokers migrate away from cigarettes, and the flavours we market are directed at helping adult smokers who are looking for a potentially less harmful alternatives to cigarettes.
“We already have third-party age verification processes for online sales. We will work with our many convenience retailers to ensure that tobacco, mint and menthol, which are our top selling flavours, remain available for consumers who are looking for potentially less harmful alternatives to cigarettes. We also have plans to make our flavoured products available in other age restricted locations, including in specialist vape stores. As with all our retail partners, we will work with any new partners who stock our products to ensure they have appropriate age verification mechanisms.
“In respect of the proposals on bringing forward the PMTA date for flavoured products, given our years of product development and scientific assessment of our vapour products, we are well-positioned to file PMTAs for our VUSE products and plan to do so ahead of the 2021 deadline.
“We will continue working with the FDA as the agency moves this proposed compliance change forward over the coming weeks. We will be submitting comments for the FDA to review and consider as the agency works to finalise the guidance document.”
Notes to Editors
(Reference to Reynolds refers to the activities undertaken by one or more of companies that comprise the RAI Group of companies)
Our presence in the US – by channel and flavours:
- Reynolds sells vapour products under the VUSE brand name. The VUSE brands include VUSE Solo, VUSE Ciro, VUSE Vibe and VUSE Alto.
- VUSE sells 12 flavour varieties with tobacco, mint and menthol flavours accounting for over 70% of our total Vuse volumes (Source: Internal data, shipments to retail (STR), kit cartridges and refill cartridges, YTD 1/1 – 9/23/18).
- Approximately 94% of VUSE consumers are over the age of 25. Moreover, over 60% of our Vuse consumers are over 35 years of age. (Source: Internal data, 1H 2018 Internal Tracker Data)
- The majority of our business for VUSE is through traditional retail and we believe this channel makes up ~45% of the industry’s sales, with over 30% in vape shops and over 20% online. (Source: Internal data, S&P with McKinsey and PWC)
Measures Reynolds already has in place to address youth access prevention:
- Reynolds has taken a responsible approach to developing, and subsequently naming, its flavours to ensure they appeal to adult consumers and not children.
- Reynolds age verifies through a third-party vendor that all potential online purchases are 21 or older.
- Reynolds is a founding member of ‘We Card’, an organisation nationally recognised for retailer education and training for age-restricted products. In 2017, We Card was recognised by 38 state governors.
- Reynolds funds ‘Right Decisions Right Now: Be Tobacco Free’ (RDRN), a youth tobacco prevention education programme which was started in 1991 and is an evidence-based, independently tested programme for use by middle-school educators, parents and community groups.
- Reynolds currently has a purchase limit of $200 per transaction and plans to implement a more stringent limit of $80 per week and three devices per quarter while instituting purchase pattern monitoring.
Reynolds has voluntarily implemented specific guidelines that restrict the content of marketing and advertising materials for our vapour products:
- No testimonials by sports figures or celebrities or any person with special appeal to persons under 21 years of age;
- No person appearing in any advertising materials shall be under age 25 or be styled to look under age 25;
- Content shall not include characters, images, or themes designed to target youth;
- Content shall not be related to youth or youth-oriented activities;
- Content shall not suggest that use of R.J. Reynolds Vapor Company’s (“RJRV”) products is essential to social prominence, distinction, success or sexual attraction, nor shall any content picture a person using any RJRV products in an exaggerated manner; and
- Content shall not depict persons participating in, or obviously just having participated in, a physical activity requiring stamina or athletic conditioning beyond that of normal recreation.
Measures we have committed to undertake in meetings with the FDA and which we are currently implementing:
- Establishing 21 as the minimum age of purchase for tobacco products in the United States.
- Supporting an abbreviated and expedited initial pre-market tobacco product application process that could have the effect of early removal of vapour products that are marketed irresponsibly.
- Not marketing RAI Group products through social media “influencers.”
- Instituting more stringent online purchase limits of $80 per week and three devices per quarter to prevent “straw” purchases
- Meeting with our nearly 200,000 contracted retailers to emphasise the importance of compliance with underage sales laws, instituting a mystery shopping programme to check compliance, and establishing an enforcement monitoring programme.
- Taking action at retail by establishing and enforcing contractual penalties for contracted retailers that sell tobacco products to youth.